Momentum vs. Value Investing: What’s the Difference?

Momentum and value investing are two distinct investment approaches with their own strengths and risks. While momentum investing relies on following existing price trends, value investing focuses on identifying undervalued shares before a market correction. Read on to learn more about the differences between these two strategies — and which might be best for you. 

What Is Momentum Investing?

Momentum investing is a strategy where investors buy stocks or other assets that have shown an upward price trend and sell those that are falling. The idea is that assets that have performed well in the recent past will continue to perform well in the near future, while underperforming assets will continue to decline. This strategy is based on the belief that trends in asset prices tend to persist over time due to investor behavior, market psychology, and sometimes economic factors. Investors typically cut losses quickly and secure profits early to avoid sharp market reversals.

Key Traits of Momentum Investing

 To identify and capitalize on price trends, momentum investors will typically:

• Focus on Price Trends

• Have Short- to Medium-Term Holding Periods

• Emphasize Relative Strength

• Use Technical Analysis

• Monitor Trading Volume

• Employ Strong Risk Management

• High Portfolio Turnover

What is Value Investing?

Value investing is a more conservative strategy that involves evaluating a company’s financial and long-term health. Value investors identify undervalued companies and buy shares at a reduced price, hoping the market will eventually correct the mispricing and recognize the asset’s true worth.

Key Traits of Value Investing

Instead of following trends like momentum investors, value investors will typically:

• Seek Undervalued Assets

• Maintain a Long-Term Investment Horizon

• Rely on Fundamental Analysis

• Prioritize a Margin of Safety

• Exercise Patience and Discipline

• Favor Stable, Established Companies

• Adopt a Risk-Averse Approach

Differences Between Momentum and Value Investing

Momentum and value investing offer contrasting approaches to the stock market, each with unique characteristics suited to different investors and market conditions.

Investment Philosophy

The core difference between momentum and value investing lies in their investment philosophy.

Momentum investing is based on the belief that trends will continue. Investors buy assets that are rising in price and sell those that are falling, aiming to profit from the continuation of these trends. It is driven by market psychology and the assumption that upward or downward momentum will continue due to investor behavior and herd mentality.

Value investing, by contrast, is built on the principle that the market sometimes misprices stocks. Value investors believe that over time, the market will correct these mispricings, and the stock’s price will rise to reflect its true intrinsic value. This approach is rooted in patience and the idea that sound fundamentals will eventually prevail over market noise.

Time Horizon

Momentum investors will typically hold stocks for weeks or months, looking to capitalize on quick price movements before the trend reverses. They focus on taking advantage of short-term market conditions and frequently adjust their portfolios to respond to new trends. 

Value investing, on the other hand, has a much longer time horizon. Value investors are willing to wait years for the market to recognize a company’s true value. Their goal is not to chase quick gains but to hold quality stocks that will appreciate slowly and steadily over time, benefiting from both price correction and long-term growth.

Analysis Type

Momentum investing relies heavily on technical analysis, which involves studying price charts, market trends, and trading volume. Momentum traders use indicators like moving averages, relative strength indexes (RSI), and other technical tools to identify entry and exit points. Their focus is more on price patterns and historical data than on the financial health of a company.

Value investing focuses on long-term potential rather than short-term price action. Value investors perform fundamental analysis on a company by examining its earnings, book value, cash flow, and debt. They compare the company’s intrinsic value to its market price to identify if it is undervalued.

Risk Level

Due to its reliance on short-term price movements, momentum investing is generally considered a high-risk strategy. Since trends can reverse quickly, momentum traders face the risk of sharp downturns and rapid losses if they fail to exit positions in time. Moreover, because momentum is largely influenced by market sentiment and investor behavior, it can be unpredictable and volatile.

Value investing tends to be lower risk because it focuses on finding discounted stocks that are fundamentally sound. By buying stocks at a discount to their intrinsic value, value investors create a “margin of safety” which can protect against downside risk. Although value stocks may take longer to appreciate, they are generally viewed as more stable and less susceptible to extreme volatility than momentum-driven stocks.

Market Behavior

Whether the market is bullish or bearish, as long as clear trends are established, momentum investors can profit. They rely on the assumption that prices will continue to move in their current direction, making this strategy particularly effective during periods of significant market momentum and sentiment-driven trading.

Value investors, by contrast, often succeed in markets with mispricings, especially during downturns or corrections when stocks may be temporarily undervalued. In volatile or bear markets, value investors may find more opportunities as others sell stocks that are temporarily out of favor.

Source of Returns

Momentum investors seek to profit from market timing, buying stocks that are on the rise and selling them before the trend reverses. They rely on quick shifts in stock prices and can often experience rapid gains (or losses) over short periods.

By purchasing stocks at a discount to their intrinsic value, value investors profit when the stock price rises to reflect its true worth. In addition, value stocks often pay dividends, providing another steady source of income over the long term.

Momentum vs. Value Investing: Which Is Better?

Neither strategy is inherently better than the other; each has its advantages depending on market conditions and individual investor preferences. Value investing appeals to those with a long-term, conservative approach. It is also a more forgiving strategy for beginner or less active investors since the longer general time frame allows prices to rebound before major goals like retirement. Momentum investing is more suited to those comfortable with higher risk and short-term market movements. While this strategy is riskier compared to value investing, momentum investors may be able to take profits more quickly — ideal if you’re investing for a shorter-term goal, like buying a new car. 

As always, consider your risk tolerance, investment time frame, and goals when choosing the right strategy for you. Consulting a financial advisor may also help you determine which method aligns with your objectives.

The article “Momentum vs. Value Investing: What’s the Difference?” first appeared on MarketBeat.